URA issues guidelines for shop sizes in new developments

The Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) has come out with a set of guidelines for shoebox shops in all new developments with retail floor area. A minimum average retail unit size and minimum corridor widths are required.

In a blog post, National Development Minister Khaw Boon Wan said the guidelines were done in consultation with industry players and said that the guidelines take a fair, balanced approach.

They give developers and architects the flexibility to propose a suitable mix of larger and smaller shops for their developments.

At the same time, they benefit shoppers and retailers, ensuring that all new developments have a good mix of shops and incorporate the latest Universal Design principles to accommodate all shoppers — including families with strollers and wheelchair users.

Mr Khaw said there is concern that developers want to build mainly shoebox shops, some that are smaller than a car park lot.

Recently, a number of developers who have pushed for shoebox apartments and factories have turned their attention to push for shoebox shops.

The URA has received applications from them proposing to build malls featuring mainly shoebox shops, with sizes as small as nine square metres. At nine sqm, the shop will be even smaller than a car park lot.

Mr Khaw said in many cases, the number of proposed shops in their proposed redevelopments will end up more than 10 times the number of shops in the original malls.

He said small shops have a place in Singapore’s retail landscape as these support entrepreneurs and cater to certain trades, such as stationery shops, florists and moneychangers.

But when these are the predominant shop type in a shopping mall, URA has to be concerned about the viability of these shops and the shopping experience of the customers.

He said industry stakeholders, including the Real Estate Developers’ Association of Singapore and the Singapore Institute of Architects, shared the URA’s concerns as well.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 26 Mar 2013

Retailers say Reits are pushing up rental costs

Real estate investment trusts (Reits) have become an investment darling in Singapore giving investors attractive returns.

But for retailers, Reits are causing them to cough out more in rents.

This is because Reits act mainly to boost returns for their shareholders.

President of the Singapore Retailers Association (SRA), Jannie Chan, says the higher rentals are adding to the woes in the retail sector which include a labour crunch and shortage of parking space.

Ms Chan says: “We’ve got the Reits killing us, we’ve got the labour killing us, and we’ve got no shopping (centre) car parks, so where are we going? So I think this is really (the result) of the government policies.”

In Singapore, up to 75 percent of a retailer’s costs are fixed costs such as rents and wages.

And over the years, the Singapore Retailers Association says rents, as a proportion of fixed costs, have risen relative to wages.

SRA says mall landlords like Reit managers raise rents by 5 to 10 percent every three years.

Ms Chan says: “(The make up of ) the fixed costs for retailers have shifted from 50 percent rental and 50 percent staff costs to 50 percent rental and 25 percent staff costs. The leases are short-term – it’s renewed every three years. Each time there is a renewal, (the retailer or tenant) has to pay between 5 and 10 percent more.”

She adds: “If your business is surviving, or doing well, you could afford that raise. But if not, you would then have to move, which means that the investments you have made over the last three years – the renovation, the staff – you may have to pull out. That becomes quite damaging, especially when you have been there for a long time and (is) there for the long haul within the shopping centre. So I think the Reits should be more mindful. If you have clients that over a period have been supportive of you, but during a certain period when there’s a downturn in the economy, they could make adjustments and be more reasonable and more compassionate.”

Speaking at the World Retail Congress, a retail industry event, which was attended by over 500 retail professionals, Ms Chan suggests that Reits could moderate their shareholders’ expectations of yields.

And this can then translate to more reasonable increases in rents.

She says: “Perhaps there could be a policy to set the Reit off between 4 and 5 percent, instead of 7 to 8 percent. At the end of the day, it’s what sort of returns (being delivered) to the investor. And at a time like this, when you’ve got very low interest rates, that seems to be compatible and reasonable.”

Other industry experts say the problems that Singapore retailers face are not unique.

Ian Mcgarrigle, Chairman, World Retail Congress, says: “For Singapore retailers, the key issue seems to be the high fixed costs that they have to operate with – the rent that they are paying for space and the high cost of labour, and also the increasing scarcity of labour. They’re not issues that surprise me – we hear them to greater or lesser degree around the world.”

CapitaMall Trust (CMT) is one of the biggest mall landlords in Singapore.

A spokesperson from CapitaMall Trust Management says it is an industry norm to have rental reversions every three years, regardless of a Reit or non-Reit regime.

Some experts believe higher rents are justified as these Reit managers upgrade mall properties to improve its business mix and customer flow.

In the 2012 financial year, CMT revealed that it raised rents across its portfolio of malls by an average of 6 percent from preceding rental rates, typically committed three years ago.

“At an average of 2 percent a year, the change in rental is lower than inflation in Singapore,” said the CapitaMall Trust Management Limited spokesperson.

The current inflation rate is around 4 percent.

The spokesperson added that the trust manager’s approach is to partner its retailers to drive shopper traffic to their malls and increase their sales.

“For example, last year, we held 13 Biz+ seminars, workshops and classes in areas such as customer relationship management and visual merchandising. These initiatives help retailers to increase business in our malls,” said the spokesperson.

Another major Reit manager, Frasers Centrepoint Trust management, was not available for comment.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 20 Mar 2013

Orchard Gateway: Orchard Rd set to welcome new mall

Singapore’s prime shopping belt Orchard Road is set to welcome a new mall, Orchard Gateway, around November this year.

Its marketing agent Savills said 80 per cent of the retail space has already been pre-committed.

And there will be a few new-to-market brands that will appeal to fashion-forward shoppers.

The mixed-development straddles both sides of Orchard Road and has 172,000 square feet of net lettable retail space.

Savills said the mall has managed to snag some big international names.

They include American chain Crate & Barrel, which will open its five-storey flagship store there, spanning over 20,000 square feet.

There is also multi-label fashion company I.T Hong Kong and Swatch – which will open its third mega store in Asia at Orchard Gateway.

Sulian Claire Tan-Wijaya, senior director at Savills, added: “Some of the other brand names will include J.Lindeberg, which is a fashion brand from Sweden. They will be introducing their ladies range for the first time in Singapore. There is also the US shoe brand Red Wings shoes – they will be opening their first concept store in Singapore.

“Also coming in to Orchard Gateway is Nike – they are introducing a new concept called Amplify women. We have also dedicated the entire fourth floor just for men, so it’s…very much skewed towards men’s fashion. There is also UK brand Religion, which has never been to Singapore.”

To cater to younger shoppers, Savills said the mall also has up-and-coming fashion blogshops.

Aside from the retail offerings, Orchard Gateway also has 37,000 square feet of office space and a 500-room hotel.

Some analysts said nearly 2 million square feet of retail space will come on stream in Singapore this year. About 18 per cent of the space will be located along Orchard Road, with the rest to be built in the suburban areas.

In recent years, retail rents between malls in the regional centres and Orchard Road have narrowed.

CBRE said prime Orchard Road rents were around S$31.60 per square foot per month compared to S$29.75 in suburban malls in the fourth quarter of last year.

Desmond Sim, associate director at CBRE Research, said: “The past two years, the rental premiums for Orchard Road and suburban malls, they have probably compressed from 20 over per cent to close to 10 per cent.

“Although the rents have been compressed quite a fair bit, at the end of the day, Orchard Road with the tourists influx still commands a premium.”

Barring any unforeseen events, analysts expect retail sales to remain healthy this year, supported by tourism and domestic demand.

Ku Swee Yong, CEO of International Property Advisor, said: “Retailers should not have problems with getting the revenue part of the business in place, the issue in the past two years has been the curb on employment of foreigners, the foreign worker levy has gone up, foreign worker ratio has gone down, and so for the retail players, it is more of an issue of manpower and manpower cost.”

Market watchers added that the labour shortage and increasing resistance against further rental increase from tenants will also affect retail rents going forward.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 19 Mar 2013

Room for more commercial developments in northeast S’pore

The government has been ramping up housing supply in recent years, particularly in the north-eastern part of Singapore and some analysts said there is room for more commercial developments to meet the needs of the growing population.

According to the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) and the Housing and Development Board (HDB), a total of 44,868 residential units will be completed in Sengkang and Punggol by 2016.

The nearby Pasir Ris town will also see 10,243 units in the next three years.

As a result, analysts said some of these towns may have limited shopping options.

Chia Siew Chuin, director of research and advisory at Colliers International, said: “When we look at shop space, we need to bear in mind that this excludes space used for F&B as well as entertainment space. If we were to consider the total amount of shop space available in the main areas of Sengkang, Punggol, Pasir Ris as well as Tampines, we can actually see that Sengkang and Punggol have a lower space per capita of about two square feet, compared to Tampines which has about seven square feet.”

The completion of The Seletar Mall and Waterway Point in the next two to three years would add another 780,000 square feet of retail space in the Sengkang/Punggol area.

The URA has also launched a commercial site at Punggol Point for sale on December 4 last year.

Looking ahead, as these new towns continue to grow, analysts said there is room for more shopping malls.

Responding to MediaCorp’s query, CapitaMall Trust which owns Rivervale Mall in Sengkang said it continually looks at opportunities to refresh its malls through asset enhancement initiatives to meet shoppers’ needs.

Richard Ng, head of asset management at CapitaMall Trust said, “When assessing a mall, we observe the shopper and vehicular traffic, shopper flow through the mall, purchasing patterns and tenants’ sales.”

Meanwhile, Frasers Centrepoint said as Sengkang town continues to grow, it will review Compass Point mall’s tenant mix to optimise space usage. The mall, which is located near the Sengkang MRT station, currently house 120 shops.

Frasers Centrepoint added that its joint venture project at Watertown in Punggol will also comprise a retail component – Waterway Point. The mall is expected to be completed by 2015 and will house 220 shops.

Donald Han, HSR Property Group’s special advisor, said: “In three to five years, there could be more opportunities for commercial sale of sites. Generally, these malls maybe smaller in size of less than 300,000 square feet. In some cases, they could be about 100,000 square feet to 200,000 square feet, mainly catering for the local population.”

Some analysts said one way to address the issue is for the government to release more mixed development sites in these areas. On these sites, developers will be able to build a combination of residential units and commercial shops which will also serve residents in the vicinity.

Analysts expect the government to continue to improve the range of facilities in new towns.

Lee Sze Teck, senior manager of training, research and consultancy at DWG, said: “The Masterplan review is coming up this year and we will probably see some changes to land uses. From there on, we will see how the URA is going to implement some of these changes to cater for an increase in population.”

Responding to query, HDB said more commercial facilities will be provided to serve residents as a town gets more developed.

It added that 71 shops, eating houses and supermarkets will be built in Sengkang, Punggol and Pasir Ris by 2016.

The National Development Ministry is due to release its Land Use Plan paper this week.

It will outline the government’s land use plan to support possible population growth.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 30 Jan 2013

Prime shopping space in CBD shrinks

Prime shopping space in the central business district (CBD) has shrunk.

As at end of September 2012, retail space – excluding that for drinking, eating and entertainment – has fallen by about 3 per cent, according to data by the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) which was analysed by real estate firm Colliers International.

Prints, an upmarket stationery retailer, has been looking to expand in the Orchard Road area. Its outlet at Chevron house has attracted a lot of corporate orders and bulk purchases from surrounding offices.

But its business is still lagging behind its other outlet at Ion Orchard. With space four times larger Chevron’s, Ion brings in 20 per cent more business.

The company said expanding into the Orchard Road shopping belt may also open up new opportunities. Its third outlet at CityLink Mall sees the least business.

Prints’ operation manager, Lim Fung Leng, said: “We’re still looking at areas like Orchard and VivoCity because we would like to expand into the international market and we would like to attract more tourists and those area has a lot people from different walks of life it will get more exposure for our products.”

More retail space in the CBD area has been converted for Food and Beverage purposes, according to a research by real estate agency Colliers International.

As a result, the available space for other retail use has become tighter.

Colliers International’s research head, Chia Siew Chuin, said: “Why you see more retail space or rather more F&B space is because a lot of developers and owners of retail malls know that F&B outlets are actually magnets for people. Magnets for human traffic to be locked inside their retail malls. So gone are the days when you only see 15 per cent to 20 per cent F&B space. You can see as high as 40 or 50 per cent of your total space is F&B or leisure space.”

Other analysts said prime space for F&B outlets may typically command lower rents.

Savills Singapore’s research head Alan Cheong said: “F&B commands lower rentals on a dollar-psf, gross lettable area because you have a lot of non-revenue generating activities like your kitchen and in some instances you have to provide washroom compared to retail where every single space is for revenue generating purpose.”

Except for the building housing the former DBS headquarters that will be redeveloped to include a sizeable retail space spanning 170,000 square feet, analysts don’t see much office space being converted to retail space in the CBD.

In the next five to 10 years, new condominiums will create the need for more retail space.

But analysts said these would be F&B outlets and retail stores providing basic necessities like pharmacies, mini-grocers and supermarkets for affluent residents.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 7 Jan 2013

Rent in Orchard Rd prime areas down 0.28% in Q4

Prime area rent for shopping malls and retailers in Orchard Road inched down 0.28 per cent this quarter, compared to the previous quarter.

In a report by Savills World Research, average monthly rent in prime areas in Orchard Road were S$35.1 per square foot in the fourth quarter.

This is a slight drop from the S$35.2 per square foot in Q3.

Analysts felt that this is due to adjustments in the market, as rent in the area were growing too fast previously.

Alan Cheong, director of Savills Research said the fall could be due to over-expecting the level of tourism in Singapore.

He said: “While (tourism) did increase, apparently the spending power did not quite live up to its expectation. Rent and performance in the Orchard Road belt will be dependent on tourism trade and on the state of the economy.”

More retail spaces will also be available soon.

Recently, Plaza Singapura completed its expansion works, providing 80 more shops.

A larger scale development, Orchard Gateway, will provide 180,000 square feet of retail space next year.

Analysts also say that a gloomy economic outlook ahead could also see rent fall by up to 3 per cent, and if economic growth slows, people will spend less.

Retailers may then take a hit, in turn exerting a downward pressure on rent.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 22 Dec 2012

SMRT Alpha appointed to operate retail space at S’pore Sports Hub

The Singapore Sports Hub has appointed SMRT Alpha to lease and operate 41,000 square metres of commercial retail space at the Singapore Sports Hub.

This new joint venture is a partnership between subsidiaries of SMRT and NTUC FairPrice.

The retail mall and waterfront area will feature a variety of indoor and alfresco food and beverage outlets.

For shoppers, the mall will offer a wide range of stores and amenities.

Tenants will also include a FairPrice Xtra hypermarket at the mall, providing affordable daily essentials and groceries, as well as sportswear and sporting equipment, catering to the needs of the residents and shoppers in the area.

The Singapore Sports Hub will be opened and fully operational in April 2014.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 18 Dec 2012

Retail rents narrowing between suburbs and Orchard Road, say analysts

Renting retail space at a suburban mall these days may not be very much cheaper than renting one at Orchard Road, say analysts.

Colliers International said the gap between prime retail rents in the two segments have narrowed from 17 per cent in 2009 to 12 per cent this year.

Demand for retail space in suburban malls will continue to be strong, say analysts, citing the improving quality of suburban malls.

Rentals of prime space along Orchard Road are now only 12 per cent higher than neighbourhood malls, at about S$34 to S$37 per square foot on average.

Analysts expect rentals to stay fairly resilient in 2013, even though over two million square feet of retail space is set to come on stream.

Among them, over 400,000 square feet of space will be located in Orchard Road, with the rest located in suburban areas like Jurong.

“So many new international brands are coming in because they see Singapore as a gateway to the growth regions. Landlords will definitely not come down on rent when you get these names coming in,” said Charles Ng, director of Retail Services at Colliers International.

Analysts also said that competition in the retail sector will be keen with newer malls in the market.

However they added that landlords should not have much problems finding tenants as the total vacancy rate is still at a healthy 6 per cent island wide.

Analysts have also pointed out the huge potential for growth in rental and capital value in Jurong East.

“The two new buildings, Jurong Gateway and Jem, will be seeing some relocation of jobs from Shenton Way into Jurong East… You are adding another 10,000 workers there. Within the next three years, the Jurong East retail scene will be significantly changed,” said Ku Swee Yong, CEO of International Property Advisor.

Overall, analysts expect rentals of retail space in Singapore to fall by between 1 per cent and 3 per cent this year, compared to 2011.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 7 Dec 2012

Brighter prospects for strata shops and offices

Strata commercial property such as shops and offices have been extremely popular in the primary market this year and are expected to sustain buyer interest, even in the sub-sale market, as attention is increasingly diverted away from residential and industrial segments.

Since the introduction of the seller’s stamp duty for private residential purchases in January last year, investors have flocked into non-residential strata properties, particularly in the industrial space.

In fact, the craze for strata industrial units has resulted in price and rental escalation that have affected the affordability of industrialists who are bona fide users of such properties.

Prices of multiple-user factory space surged by 8.3 per cent in 2Q 2012 from the previous quarter, after the 7.2 per cent rise in 1Q 2012. Rentals of multiple-user factory space jumped by 4 per cent in 2Q 2012 from the previous quarter.

While strata industrial units remain attractive because their price quantum is considered the lowest among all property types, investor interest is expected to moderate amid heightened concerns about affordability to industrialists and the prospects of more Government tightening measures.

New industrial leases from the Government Land Sales programme have recently been reduced to 30 years to separate end-users from investors.

Risk-averse investors concerned about price sustainability are increasingly putting purchase decisions at bay, particularly if changes to the dynamics of industrial property mean returns cannot be easily realised.

Developer sales of commercial property are timely, especially after the decades-long hiatus.

Although strata shops and offices are pricier than strata industrial properties, they will offer opportunities to buyers with deeper pockets and those who opt to invest in very small shops and offices.

There is no single mall owner to control the tenant mix in strata malls but the free-play element can potentially allow more innovations from new retailers.

These may include retailers that are not able to gain entry into established single-owner malls that emphasise retail offering compatibility.

Minimal Government intervention is expected in the strata shop space as speculation is not expected to affect viability in general. Continued marginal upside in strata shop prices within the parameters of economic performance is expected. The interest for new strata shops can extend from developer sales to sub-sales in the months ahead, reflecting interest from buyers who had missed out on the early opportunity.

But as they purchase at higher prices, there will be limited opportunity to flip the property and the buyers are likely to be long-term investors rather than speculators.

However, long-term investors in new strata shops should critically evaluate the investment potential and this extends beyond its accessibility to include the catchment population and the profile of regular shoppers. A long-term investor for strata shops also needs to recognise the risks stemming from incompatibility in the mix of retailers as there will be no central mall operator.

Strata offices were the star performers in 1H 2012, as virtually no new projects in this segment were undertaken in the past decades.

Another important driver for buying interest in strata offices is the increasing preference among businesses to own property assets to enjoy long-term operational cost certainty.

Businesses are averse to lease renewals where rents can be raised unilaterally while relocations come with significant additional costs.

The prospects for strata offices in choice locations, particularly those in mixed-use developments with retail facilities as amenities for office users, will be favourable.

Like strata shops, speculation in strata office properties purchased from developers do not essentially affect the viability of businesses in general, which predominantly are in single-owner office buildings or older strata office buildings.

Indeed, strata offices have even better ability than strata shops to hold their own as there is no major requirement for a central owner to control the occupant or tenant mix as in the case of shopping malls.

The vibrancy of the commercial sector in Singapore, as opposed to the industrial segment where operational costs are less competitive in Asia, is also reason for end-users and investors to consider buying strata offices for operations and investments.

By Ong Kah Seng Director at R’ST Research, an independent property market research and advisory company in Singapore

Source : Today – 14 Sep 2012

ERC launching Bugis Cube strata shops for sale

Riding on the strata retail property boom, Griffin Real Estate Investment Holdings, a wholly-owned subsidiary of education group ERC Holdings, is launching units for sale at Bugis Cube this Saturday.

Up to 91 strata units will be available at Bugis Cube, a six-storey, 999-year leasehold building at North Bridge Road.

It is currently undergoing a multi-million-dollar retrofitting that is expected to be completed by the middle of next year.

Investors have been driven to the non-residential segments of the property market following the Government’s imposition of harsh stamp duties on both sellers and buyers of homes last year to cool the red-hot housing sector.

Mr Andy Ong, chairman of ERC Holdings, said: “The Bugis area is one of the most vibrant shopping areas in Singapore. It is one of the few places that draw a young, trendy crowd seven days a week.

“Bugis Cube will be very attractive to retailers catering to youth and students. Furthermore, Bugis Cube is a rare opportunity for people to own prime retail property in the city centre.”

There are five MRT stations within a 10-minute walk from Bugis Cube, including the new Downtown Line Bugis interchange that will open by the end of next year, ERC said.

The firm added that the area would be enhanced by the construction of the South Beach development as well as the Rochor development by Singapore’s Temasek Holdings and Malaysia’s Khazanah Nasional.

Soure : Today – 21 Jun 2012