Orchard Road shopping malls face challenges in en bloc sale

Tanglin Shopping Centre is trying for an en bloc sale for the second time.

It failed to find a buyer on its first attempt last year at a reserve price of S$1.25 billion.

In fact, there has never been a successful en bloc sale in the Orchard Road shopping belt.

Teresa Wong purchased a freehold shop spanning 330 square feet at Far East Plaza 25 years ago.

For the beauty therapist, the need to control costs was crucial.

She said: “The landlord might ask us to leave after two or three years. So my best bid was to buy the shop and stay here permanently. When we shift, we have to renovate. And renovation cost money.”

The shop space cost S$0.5 million back then and its current value is triple that or at least S$1.6 million.

Should an en bloc sale take place, Madam Wong would only sell at double the current value or S$3 million.

Satisfying the expectations of owners with shops of varying degrees of human traffic is a major obstacle to putting a strata-titled mall on the market.

Jones Lang LaSalle’s head of investments, residential, Karamjit Singh, said: “In Orchard Road, you will always have a situation where some trades, despite the age, may be doing very good business. Whenever you have that taking place, the owners are always very reluctant to sell because there aren’t many comparable replacement properties for them to channel their investments towards.”

This could also be the challenge to getting 80 percent of the 173 owners at Tanglin Shopping Centre to approve an en bloc sale. But, it may be second time lucky for this 40-year-old mall.

Christina Sim, director for investment and capital markets at Cushman & Wakefield, said: “They have a good chance of succeeding because I don’t think there are many big ticket commercial properties right now. And with QE3 coming in, there would be some hot money coming in too. What would likely happen is that a foreign investor would team up with a local developer to do this.”

Analysts say an en bloc sale attempt could be made easier should URA’s masterplan, reviewed once every five years, indicate a new building could yield more gross floor area than the existing one.

Another push factor to convincing numerous strata titled owners in a building to agree is to an en bloc sale is the change of land use from say shops to a hotel.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 23 Oct 2012

Orchard Road: 25th most expensive retail street globally

Singapore’s famed shopping street, Orchard Road, has been ranked 25th most expensive in the world this year.

With rents of retail space averaging at S$462.43 per sq ft a year, this is a notch up from last year against 129 cities in a study conducted by Colliers International.

New York’s Fifth Avenue and Hong Kong’s Queen’s Road Central and Canton Road were the world’s top three most expensive shopping streets, commanding the highest rentals.

Published on an annual basis, the 2012 global survey tracked annual retail rents of the world’s prime retail corridors – from the first quarter of 2011 to the first quarter of 2012 – across 129 cities in North America, Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA), Asia Pacific and Latin America.

The improvement in ranking came despite prime rents in Orchard Road easing by 0.5 per cent on-year to S$459.60 per sq ft per year as of the first quarter of 2012.

On a quarter-on-quarter basis, prime rents of retail space remained unchanged in the first quarter of 2012 at S$38.30 per sq ft per month, but eased towards the second quarter by 1.9 per cent to S$37.58.

Colliers International attributed Singapore’s global rank ascent to the strengthening of the Singapore currency against the US dollar.

Charles Ng, director of Retail Services of Colliers International, added: “Additionally, tenants are observed to be more selective in the space they take up – taking into consideration the volume of pedestrian flow and position of shops in malls.

“Landlords are looking to create and maintain the retail identity and concept of their malls by stringently controlling the tenant mix. Consequently, the market experienced inertia on further rent increases.”

With growing competition for tenants and a challenging operating environment, the sector is likely to see flattening growth rental rates for the rest of the year.

But with sustained retail sales growth and more new retail brands entering Singapore, Colliers pointed out that any downward rental movement will be marginal at 3 to 5 per cent for the whole of 2012.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 11 Jul 2012

Orchard Road prime rents on the rebound

Prime rents in Orchard Road have rebounded for the first time in nearly three years. That is according to a study by real estate consultancy CB Richard Ellis.

Rents rose 5 per cent from the second quarter of 2011, to average S$31.60 per square foot per month. Rents were S$30.11 per square foot per month in the last quarter.

The upturn follows a series of dips since 2008, when rents peaked at more than S$36 per square foot.

CBRE said new malls have attracted more retailers and have also forced a revamp of older properties.

It noted that there is almost full occupancy at shopping centres on Orchard Road, with a dominance by fast fashion brands. Retailers to have opened recently include swedish fashion house H&M at Orchard Building. Abercrombie & Fitch is set to open at the end of the year.

The biggest decrease was in 2009, when prime rents dropped to S$32.40 psf/month, a 10.2 per cent decrease from 2008.

Letty Lee, Director of Retail Services at CB Richard Ellis, said: “We are witnessing almost full occupancy at Orchard Road malls.

“New-to-market brands continue to actively explore taking up Orchard Road space, encouraged by fresh opportunities offered by newly available large prime space including the recent exit of Borders at Wheelock Properties. Rentals should hold steady for the fourth quarter.”

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 4 Oct 2011

Orchard Road rents move up a spot in global ranking

Orchard Road has moved up one place in the global ranking of rents because of the strong Singapore dollar.

It moved up a notch to 26th place in the Global Retail Survey 2011 carried out by Colliers International.

However, Orchard Road moved down a spot to seventh place in the Asia Pacific region in 2011 with the inclusion of Hong Kong’s Queen’s Road in the latest survey on rents in the world’s premier shopping districts.

Prime rents in Orchard Road had increased by 10.8 per cent year-on-year to US$366 per square foot per year in the first quarter of 2011, according to Colliers International Research.

However, in local currency terms, it remained unchanged at S$462 per square foot per year.

The hike in rent was due to the strengthening of the Singapore dollar against the US currency.

While the Orchard Road retail market is still adjusting to the influx of over 1.3 million square feet of new retail space in 2009, prime rents in Orchard Road are now more competitive than those in the premier retail corridors of Hong Kong, Sydney, Tokyo and Brisbane this year.

Nevertheless, Colliers International said that with the expected healthy tourism arrivals and positive consumer sentiment, there is a possibility for retailers in Orchard Road to record some profits for 2011.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 13 Jun 2011

Orchard retail space oversupply?

A number of shopping malls opened in Orchard Road in the last two years, increasing the prime shopping belt’s retail space by about 30 per cent, but not everyone at these new spaces has been doing well.

Only last week, tenants at 313 Somerset reportedly petitioned for lower rentals, complaining of poor business, raising questions over whether there is an oversupply of retail space in the area.

Mr Colin Tan, head of research and consultancy at Suntec Chesterton International, said: “If you go down to Orchard Road and visit some of these places, you’ll see that there is a high turnover of tenants. Tenants, which may have signed three years ago, are now finding it very hard to cope, so you see a lot of empty shops or hoardings or signs.”

There were signs of sluggish demand creeping in during the first quarter this year. Vacancy rates for Orchard Road retail space inched up to 6 per cent from 5 per cent from the fourth quarter last year.

Mr Nicholas Mak, head of research and consultancy at SLP International, said: “In the last two quarters, demand has not been as fast. As a result, some of the malls may have to adjust their rentals to attract new tenants or retain some of the existing ones.”

Others say the situation may not be so straightforward.

Senior manager for research at Cushman & Wakefield Ong Kah Seng said: “There has been a long dearth of major malls in Orchard Road – for more than a decade. The new malls actually refresh the identity of Orchard Road but require some time to be adjusted by market participants as they arrived as a surge after a hiatus.”

Source : Today – 28 May 2011

Orchard road malls going for frequent facelifts

Shopping malls along Orchard Road are going for facelifts even though they are relatively new, due to rising competition from brand-new shopping centres – which are forcing the existing ones to spruce up their act.

Instead of refurbishing a shopping centre after a decade or two, mall owners are tweaking the look and feel of even relatively new buildings.

Analysts say this is because the ownership of many shopping centres has changed hands, and the new landlords are real-estate investment trusts that want to earn high rental incomes to keep their investors satisfied.

Head of research for Jones Lang Laselle (SEA), Dr Chua Yang Liang says the arrival of real-estate investment trusts (REITs) have made mall operators more aggressive.

“Because at the end of the day, you have your major shareholders, it’s about income returns on the asset itself, so there is motivation to make sure their assets are viable and continue to attract the tenants”, said Dr Chua.

Wisma Atria shopping mall on Orchard Road will be getting a facelift by the third quarter of next year.

It is owned by Starhill Global REIT, which plans to enhance the mall’s positioning by redeveloping its frontage.

Meanwhile, CapitaMall Trust has announced asset enhancements initiatives in Atrium@Orchard.

Analysts say the trend is likely to continue.

“So there is that change in structure, and definitely going forward, I think you may see the retail scene, especially along Orchard Road changing along towards that direction”, said Dr Chua.

“Where the lifespan of the building becomes shorter, and the need to upgrade becomes more pressing.”

Following the launch of several new malls along Orchard Road over the last two years – such as the Knightsbridge at Grand Park Orchard hotel, Ion Orchard, Orchard Central and 313@Somerset – analysts expect the premier shopping belt to see less new addition of retail space next year.

“There is already a fair amount of malls and that have already cropped up. So after this round of refurbishment, the situation will probably stabilize over the next couple of years”, said Mr Wong Sui Jau, general manager of Fundsupermart.

Currently, the monthly gross rent in the Orchard Road area is between S$20 and S$40 per square foot.

According to Jones Lang LaSalle, prime rents have risen 1 per cent over the past one year.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 2 Mar 2011

Orchard Road gears up for 2011

Analysts say malls across Singapore will be stepping up their game next year, now that retail spending looks set to increase due to robust growth and higher tourism arrivals.

More landmark developments will be open from next year, on the stretch of the iconic Orchard Road.

Orchard Road Business Association executive director Steven Goh said: “…Orchard Road is a street where it continues to reinvent itself.

“And you will see another opening of a new mall, Scotts Square, in the third quarter of 2011, (and) the anticipated H&M opening in the third quarter, as well as (at) the old Specialist Centre and Orchard Emerald.

“It’s been announced they are going to open up 250,000 square feet of retail, hotel and office space.

But with so many malls on Orchard Road, some retailers may find it hard to draw in the crowds.

Others believe that with more hotels and residences on Orchard Road, retail spending will surge.

“…Orchard Road is traditionally a launching pad for most of the new international brands coming to town. So we will foresee that to continue (evolving) along Orchard Road,” Mr Goh said.

“At the same time, there will be new hotel rooms — at least 500 to 600 (of them) on Orchard Road in the next four years”.

Orchard Residences, which has 175 units, will be completed by end of this year, while the 338-unit Scotts Square will be completed in 2011.

Meanwhile, older malls are also seeking a fresh start amid the stiff competition.

For example, the Tanglin Shopping Centre and the former Paradiz Centre POMO are now up for sale.

More suburban malls like Nex should emerge soon enough.

Temasek Polytechnic’s Retail Management course manager Samuel Tan said: “I think the suburban malls have a lot to offer because they have strong catchment and good traffic footfall.

“That itself forms a very strong reason for the shopping mall to be set up there.

“Nex has two supermarkets under one roof — they have FairPrice as well as Cold Storage, they have Kopitiam as well as other other food court operators. I think all this does give the consumers better variety”.

While shops can look forward to thicker profits, the outlook for retail investment is cautious.

Colliers International director of retail Charles Ng said: “We have the Ion, Orchard Central, 313, Mandarin Gallery and Knightsbridge. So that’s quite a lot of space on Orchard Road.

“There’s abundant supply, but having said that, (the) take up rate is quite healthy and so rents have remained stable as a result of that”.

Rentals for prime shopping space are about S$40 per square foot per month.

And the year ahead should see retail rentals growing slightly.

“With the economy growing at four to six per cent, I think retail rents will even inch up if you ask me. For suburban areas, maybe one to two per cent at least,” Mr Ng said.

“Orchard Road should see a bigger growth – it can grow up to about five per cent.”

Analysts add that with the new Marina Bay Sands, nearby office buildings in the central business district will attract big brand names.

MAC Cosmetics, The Hourglass and Swarovski Crystals are some stores which have set up branches in the district.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 23 Dec 2010

New retail, hotel & office project on Orchard Road

Singapore’s Orchard Road will be adding another new face to its shopping belt.

A retail, hotel and office development will soon come up at the sites of the former Specialists’ Centre and Hotel Phoenix, as well as Orchard Emerald mall.

The project, costing some S$700 million, is expected to be completed in the second half of 2013.

A groundbreaking ceremony on Friday marked the start of the redevelopment of three neighbouring sites on Orchard Road.

Where the former Specialists’ Centre and Hotel Phoenix used to be, a new 4-star hotel with about 500 rooms will come up, along with nearly 21,000 square metres of retail space.

United Engineers (UEL) is the developer of the site, which is wholly owned by OCBC.

Across the road, the former Orchard Emerald site will contain around 3,500 square metres of office space and 2,700 square metres of retail space. The site is wholly-owned and developed by Great Eastern Holdings.

The two sites will be connected by a glass overhead bridge across Orchard Road, which developer UEL said is the first in Singapore.

UEL is not concerned that its new development is a relatively latecomer in the saturated Orchard Road shopping strip.

Jackson Yap, CEO, United Engineers Limited, said: “We are the last of the jigsaw that would make this into a significant shopping area. The key to this is connectivity.

“You can go seamlessly in bad weather and so on, into the three shopping malls. You can cross the street, and also shop on the other side of the road.”

The new development will also be connected by passageways to its neighbours 313@Somerset and Orchard Central. Its Basement 1 will also be connected to the Somerset MRT station.

UEL said it is confident it can generate decent foot traffic.

Mr Yap said: “Phoenix Hotel has always been well-occupied, partly because of its location and also its proximity to many shopping malls. So we expect the hotel to be full and the hotel is full because we have good shopping tenants!”

A key tenant will be a new Singapore Visitors Centre, but the developers are keeping mum on the retail mix for now.

Observers say the new development may also feature some high-end brands, given Orchard Road’s reputation as a premier shopping belt.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 16 Jul 2010

Orchard Road ranked 27th most expensive retail street in world: survey

Singapore prime Orchard Road shopping belt has been ranked the 27th most expensive retail street in the world by property consultant Colliers International.

The city moved up one notch from the 28th spot last year in the Colliers annual global ranking of rents for prime retail space.

Colliers said prime retail space along Orchard Road is US$330.19 per square foot per year on average. This was up about 2 per cent over the last survey in 2009.

Colliers Director of Research and Advisory Tay Huey Ying said the gain is due to the weakening of the US dollar against the Singapore unit.

But in Singapore dollar terms, rents for prime retail space on Orchard Road fell 5.5 per cent on-year in the first quarter.

Elsewhere, Colliers said street front rents in almost every region of the world fell during the past 12 months for a second consecutive year.

Colliers said despite an improved global economic landscape, retailers were still expressing caution in terms of expanding and committing to new stores.

But it also noted that there is mounting evidence that the worst of the downturn is over and high-end retailers would be back pressing for more high profile stores.

In particular, it said two sub-categories – financial centres and tourism-dependent cities – were doing better relative to the previous year.

It said, with many of the world’s rich feeling more secure and comfortable with luxury purchases, demand for high-end retail premises is expected to increase over the coming year.

In addition, with the improving global economy and credit markets, retailers with a strong balance sheet are quickly gaining the confidence to expand into markets previously viewed as too expensive or difficult to penetrate.

Colliers said the emergence of a sizeable middle class in Asia Pacific, the Middle East and central and eastern Europe will likely continue, and these “aspirational” consumers will be a key source of growth for many luxury retailers.

The Colliers survey is published annually and tracks annual retail rents of the world’s prime retail corridors across 127 cities in North America, Europe, Middle East and Africa, Asia Pacific and Latin America.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 8 Jun 2010

Prime Orchard Road rental decline slowed in Q1: CB Richard Ellis

Property consultant CB Richard Ellis said the pace of prime Orchard Road rental decline slowed in the first quarter this year.

In a research report, it noted that prime Orchard Road rents averaged S$32.20 per square foot per month in the first quarter, down by just 0.7 per cent on-quarter.

Rents had declined between 1.5 per cent and 3.3 per cent in the previous four quarters.

Prime suburban rents, meanwhile, remained stable at S$28.10 per square foot per month in the first quarter, unchanged from the previous three months.

CBRE said F&B operations continue to flourish with more 24-hour grocers and cafes.

It added that the year ahead will be “interesting” for the retail space, with the imminent opening of the Circle Line and the completion of the two integrated resorts.

As for investment transactions, CBRE said the first quarter has been characterised by sales within the same group.

For example, over the period, it noted that Frasers Centrepoint Trust announced plans to buy two malls from Frasers Centrepoint Mall.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 7 Apr 2010